Using composite criticism we look at the work, in this case, Schitt’s Creek, from a realistic perspective for ourselves and the shows intended viewers. The intrinsic appreciation aspect of the critique is based on the enjoyment that the work might get from its viewers. “The purpose of intrinsic appreciation is exclusively the apprehension of the “pleasure-successes” achieved by the work.” pg.476 The main idea here is to acknowledge what the work is trying to portray and if they do a good job. The “pleasure” that Schitt’s Creek is trying to get out of their viewers is laughter. Because it is a comedy which includes fun features creating, “pleasure-potent aesthetics” pg.476
Intrinsic evaluation is looked at with negative and positive views while in the critical process. This estimates the worth of the show without the knowledge of how it was supposed to be delivered or what the audiences reaction will be. This also reveals how the program has leverage in its genre. Schitt’s creek is intended to be a comedy but, “We must consider the work within its genre, the intrinsic evaluation does not stop there. It also proceeds to judge the project as a complete novel property.” pg.481
When it comes to the extrinsic parts of the critique we can start with extrinsic appreciation. This considers what obstacles the work had to go through to get to the finished product. Things such as budget, available promotion, and traditional programing. “Extrinsic appreciation is essential in bringing realistic sympathy for the work of the critical task.” pg.479
The extrinsic evaluation focuses on how the work affects public viewers. “Focusing on specific effects of the work on audiences and the subsequent effects of audiences of the work.” pg.484 This could be used to critique Schitt’s Creek by acknowledging that many can relate to the themes within the show regarding social class. Using all four of these perspectives makes for viewing the work in a realistic process that professionals, consumers, and critics can understand.
Vic's Blog 